|
WINDY CITY TIMES
|
|
|
Supreme court recognizes family changes
2000-06-07
|
|
This article shared 1468 times since Wed Jun 7, 2000
|
|
Making its strongest statements yet on changing family structures, the U.S. Supreme Court Monday struck down an expansive Washington visitation statute and rejected an appeal by a couple seeking more time with their grandchildren.
The Justices, Lambda Legal Defense and Education Fund noted, were careful not to foreclose protections for lesbian, gay, and other non-biological parents.
"This is a very important decision for lesbian and gay families, who are at the forefront of family law changes. The Court adopted a sound, middle course in this case, one that not only appropriately respects the rights of parents, but acknowledges that no hard-and-fast rule should govern every single family dispute," said Deputy Legal Director Ruth E. Harlow, co-author of an amicus brief in Troxel v. Granville.
The Justices splintered 6-3 in the case, producing six separate opinions. The plurality opinion by Justice Sandra Day O'Connor held that the Constitution requires that "material weight" be given to the views of parents regarding the control and care of their children, although the decision does not suggest that parents have an absolute veto over those matters. Mindful that " [ t ] he demographic changes of the past century make it difficult to speak of an average American family," and that many people take on "duties of a parental nature," the Court also decided the case narrowly to avoid broad legal pronouncements with adverse consequences for other kinds of familial relationships.
The Troxel case was brought by a Washington couple who sought more visitation time with two girls, ages 10 and 8, over the objections of the girls' mother and turned on an exceptionally broad Washington statute allowing "any person" to petition for visitation at "any time."
Lambda's brief, filed with Gay & Lesbian Advocates & Defenders, had urged the Court to strike down the law as overly broad. But in the interest of non-biological lesbian and gay parents who, unlike the grandparents in this case, have unusually significant relationships warranting protection, the brief also urged the Justices to take a balanced approach and avoid an overly expansive view of parental autonomy and control.
The Supreme Court found the visitation statute unconstitutional without endorsing the Washington Supreme Court's analysis in its 1999 ruling, which made the rights of parents almost absolute. The Justices, who rarely make forays into family law, an area normally reserved for state courts, left unanswered what standards will pass constitutional muster, saying only that the Washington law does not, according to Lambda Legal Defense.
"Gay parents sometimes must defend themselves from legal challenges by meddling third parties who disapprove of the parents' sexual orientation, while non-biological parents can be shut out of their children's lives entirely," said Supervising Attorney Patricia M. Logue, who also co-authored the Lambda brief. Logue, from Chicago, added, "This ruling provides hope for families who face both of these painful situations."
|
|
|
|
This article shared 1468 times since Wed Jun 7, 2000
|
ARTICLES YOU MIGHT LIKE |
---|
|
| | News is Out, Word In Black, Comcast NBCUniversal welcomes 16 Journalism Fellows to cover Black, LGBTQ+ communities 2024-04-16 - Philadelphia (April 15, 2024) — Today, News is Out and Word In Black, together announced the 16 fellows selected for The Digital Equity Local Voices Lab, a new initiative powered by Comcast NBCUniversal to place journalists ...
|
| | Brittney Griner, wife expecting first baby 2024-04-15 - Brittney Griner is expecting her first child with wife Cherelle Griner. According to NBC News, the couple announced on Instagram that they are expecting their baby in July. "Can't believe we're less than three months away ...
|
| | VIEWPOINT Meditation on the killing of journalists 2024-04-11 - Trigger warning: I am a journalist and I read newspapers. I've been reading newspapers since I first learned to read. Newspapers were a lively part of the daily life in my family. I even wrote letters ...
|
| | Ella Matthes, award-winning publisher, editor of Lesbian News Magazine, dies at 81 2024-04-05 --From an ILDKMedia press release - Los Angeles, CA - Ella Matthes, longtime publisher and editor of Lesbian News Magazine, passed away from a heart attack on March 16, 2024 at The Little Company of Mary hospital in Norwalk, California. She was ...
|
| | WORLD Lesbian sniper, HIV research, marriage items, Chinese singer, Korean festival 2024-04-05 - A lesbian Ukrainian sniper and her machine-gun-toting girlfriend are taking the fight to Russia President Vladimir Putin, according to a Daily Beast article. Olga—a veterinarian-turned-soldier—said her comrades don't care about ...
|
| | NATIONAL mpox, Trans+ Day of Visibility, police items, Best Buy, Gentili's death 2024-04-05 - The CDC has concluded that mpox cases are on the rise in the United States, increasing to almost double what they were at the same time last year, according to ABC News. There is a national year-to-date estimate of 511 cases ...
|
| | SHOWBIZ Dionne Warwick, OUTshine, Ariana DeBose, 'Showgirls,' 'Harlem' 2024-03-29 Video below - Iconic singer Dionne Warwick was honored for her decades-long advocacy work for people living with HIV/AIDS at a star-studded amfAR fundraising gala in Palm Beach, per the Palm Beach Daily News. Warwick received the "Award of ...
|
| | The Jeff Awards announces the 50th anniversary awards for non-equity theater 2024-03-26 --From a press release - A complete list of recipients can also be found online in the Non-Equity and News and Events sections at www.jeffawards.org. (March 25, 2024 - Chicago) — Celebrating its 50th anniversary awarding recognition for Non-Equity theater, the ...
|
| | NATIONAL Altercation, mpox research, Univ. of Fla., George Santos, tech battle 2024-03-08 - Video footage uploaded to Facebook showed an altercation between a state trooper and two prominent Philadelphia LGBTQ+ leaders, the Washington Blade reported, republishing an article from Philadelphia Gay News. Celena ...
|
| | NATIONAL School items, HIV/AIDS activist dies, Nex Benedict, inclusive parade 2024-03-01 - In a new survey, the Pew Research Center asked public K-12 teachers, teens and the U.S. public about the ongoing scrutiny placed on classroom curricula, mainly regarding race and LGBTQ+ identities, ABC News noted. Among other ...
|
| | Appeals court allows Ind. ban on gender-affirming care for minors 2024-03-01 - On Feb. 27, a federal appeals court in Chicago allowed Indiana's ban on gender-affirming care to go into effect, removing a temporary injunction that U.S. District Court Judge James Patrick Hanlon issued last year, ABC News ...
|
| | Oklahoma non-binary student dies after being assaulted 2024-02-21 - Officials acknowledged there are unresolved questions about a 16-year-old non-binary Oklahoma student who died one day after a fight in a high school bathroom, NBC News noted. Chuck Hoskin Jr., principal chief of the Cherokee Nation, ...
|
| | Democrat flips seat once held by George Santos 2024-02-14 - On Feb. 13 in New York, Democrat Tom Suozzi won a special election to succeed the U.S. congressional seat formerly held by openly gay Republican George Santos, who was recently ousted. According to NBC News, Suozzi's ...
|
| | Comcast NBCUniversal partners with News is Out, Word In Black on fellowship program highlighting Black, LGBTQ+ issues 2024-02-06 --From a press release - Digital Equity Local Voices Lab Fellows to be placed at 16 local publications to receive training and create content Philadelphia (Feb. 6, 2024) — News is Out [ https://newsisout.com ] , a queer media collaborative of ...
|
| | NATIONAL Marriage news, fighting fentanyl, anti-LGBTQ+ crimes, Grindr 2024-02-02 - The Virginia House of Delegates passed a bill that would affirm marriage equality in the state, The Washington Blade noted. House Bill 174, introduced by state Del. Rozia Henson (D-Prince William County), passed in the Democratic-controlled ...
| |
|
|
|
|