WASHINGTON, D.C—More than 3,000 faith leaders and clergy sent a letter today to members of Congress urging their opposition to the First Amendment Defense Act ( H.R. 2802 ). The letter ( full text below this release ), coordinated by Bend the Arc: A Jewish Partnership for Justice and Auburn Seminary, was delivered today to Representatives Jason Chaffetz and Elijah Cummings, the Chair and Ranking Member of the U.S. House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform, which is currently considering the bill. The letter was also shared with every member of the U.S. House of Representatives.
In the letter, the signatories argue that this legislation undermines true religious liberty and opens the door to unprecedented taxpayer-funded discrimination against LGBT people, single mothers and unmarried couples.
"As clergy and faith leaders, we must declare unequivocally that we will not allow hateful laws to be passed in the name of religion or religious liberty," said Rabbi Jason Kimelman-Block, Rabbi-in-Residence at Bend the Arc: A Jewish Partnership for Justice and a signatory of the letter. "I am appalled that some members of Congress are distorting the meaning of religious freedom to advocate for discriminatory legislation. Their actions are undermining true religious liberty. What they don't seem to understand is that the Constitution guarantees all Americans the freedom to hold any belief we choose — but it does not allow us to discriminate against others in the name of our beliefs. As a rabbi and as an American, I stand by the right of all Americans to hold beliefs that I may find objectionable, but I will not tolerate efforts to make those beliefs the basis for legal discrimination against the LGBT community."
In the letter, the clergy and faith leaders outline how the First Amendment Defense Act could lead to widespread discrimination. For example, were this bill to become law, it would:
- Allow discrimination against LGBT individuals or anyone who has a sexual relationship outside of marriage by organizations like homeless shelters and drug treatment programs that receive government funding;
- Allow hospitals and hospices to deny LGBT and unmarried couples spousal visitation rights;
- Allow government officials to refuse to dispense benefits or services like Veteran or Social Security benefits to the surviving member of a same-sex couple.
Bend the Arc has been a leader among Jewish and other faith groups pushing for LGBT equality. In 2008, the organization mobilized its supporters in California against Proposition 8. In recent years, Bend the Arc has also signed onto amicus briefs advocating for marriage equality in the landmark cases that struck down the Defense of Marriage Act and established marriage equality as the law of the land.
Bend the Arc: A Jewish Partnership for Justice is a national organization inspired by Jewish values and the steadfast belief that Jewish Americans, regardless of religious or institutional affiliations, are compelled to create justice and opportunity for Americans.
FULL TEXT OF LETTER July 21, 2015
Faith Leaders Oppose the First Amendment Defense Act (H.R. 2802)
Dear Chairman Chaffetz and Ranking Member Cummings:
As clergy and faith leaders who serve diverse communities across the United States and are dedicated to affirming the religious freedom of every individual, we write to express our opposition to the First Amendment Defense Act (H.R. 2802).
The religious liberty upon which our nation was founded has allowed our country's diverse religious landscape to flourish. Recently, however, what we have seen promoted as defending religious liberty too often reflects one particular religious perspective that does not at all respect that diversity of faith and belief, or the intent of our Founders. We believe that the First Amendment Defense Act does not respect the spirit of religious liberty—nor does it reflect fundamental values of treating all people with fairness and equality—and we therefore strongly oppose this legislation. Further, though people of faith are not a monolith and all are not in agreement on whether their faith sanctions LGBT relationships, we cannot in good conscience support legislation that favors one religious viewpoint over another and in the process discriminates against LGBT people, single mothers and unmarried couples.
The religious freedom of individuals and organizations, including clergy and houses of worship, who object to same-sex marriage are already protected by the First Amendment and federal law—and we, as clergy and faith leaders, continue to stand by the right of others to hold beliefs that may differ from our own while recognizing that for many of us, supporting LGBT individuals and families is a principle of our faith. Rather than protecting the First Amendment, this legislation actually undermines true religious liberty. The religious liberty on which our nation was founded guarantees us the freedom to hold any belief we choose and the right to act on our religious beliefs — but it does not allow us to harm or discriminate against others or to infringe on the religious beliefs of others.
By opening the door to unprecedented taxpayer-funded discrimination against LGBT people, single mothers and unmarried couples, this legislation does nothing to protect our rights as people of diverse faith traditions and it has the potential to do considerable harm in the name of religion. For example, were this bill to become law it would:
- allow an organization to accept federal funds to run a homeless shelter or drug treatment program but then turn away from that program LGBT people or anyone who has a sexual relationship outside of marriage;
- allow hospitals to refuse dying patients visitation from their spouse or designated support person; and
- permit a government employee to deny services they have a duty to provide, including Veterans or Social Security benefits to a surviving member of a same-sex couple.
We are also troubled that this bill is so broad it could even prevent the federal government from enforcing longstanding laws designed to combat discrimination and promote equality. For example, it would let commercial landlords violate fair housing laws by refusing housing to a single mother based on the landlord's religious beliefs and allow businesses to violate family medical leave laws by refusing to let a gay or lesbian employee care for a sick spouse.
As people of deep faith committed to a country that supports diverse, robust, and healthy religious expression and in the spirit of equality and justice, we urge you to oppose the First Amendment Defense Act.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,*
Bishop Gene Robinson
Rabbi Jason Kimelman-Block, Rabbi-in-Residence, Bend the Arc: A Jewish Partnership for Justice
Stosh Cotler, President and CEO, Bend the Arc: A Jewish Partnership for Justice
Rev. Elder Nancy Wilson, Moderator of the Universal Fellowship of Metropolitan Community Churches
The Rev. Fred Davie, Executive Vice President, Union Theological Seminary
The Rev. Barry Lynn, Executive director of Americans United for Separation of Church and State
Rabbi Denise Eger, President of the Central Conference of American Rabbis
Rabbi Jack Moline, Executive Director of Interfaith Alliance
Reverend Harry Knox, resident and Chief Executive Officer of the Religious Coalition for Reproductive Choice (RCRC)
Sister Simone Campbell, Executive Director of NETWORK
Pastor Brian McLaren
*Note: Listed here are some of the most prominent signatories, each of whom signed as individuals, not as representatives of their various organizations.
