Search Articles
Advanced Search
  About Us   WCMG Info   Publications   QueerCast   Blogs   Videos   Advertisers   Events/Lists   OUT! Guide

    

    

    


Windy City Times Current DownloadNightspots Current DownloadQueercast Current DownloadVideocast Current DownloadWindy City Media Group BlogsJoin Our Email List!
Click here for only most current editions; click on red bars above for past editions.
  Windy City Times
Legal victory in transgendered rights: F to M's marriage to woman upheld
by Deb Price
2003-03-05
Eighteen years ago, Margot Kantaras was a frightened 24-year-old woman feeding quarters into a pay phone, frantically trying to track down a Texas clinic that she'd heard could change her into the man she'd always felt she truly was.

No longer a woman and no longer frightened, Michael -- who left his former Margot identity behind in Texas after surgery and hormones -- recently won the most significant legal victory to date in the newly emerging area of transgendered rights.

Ruling in a bitter divorce and child-custody dispute, a Florida judge on Feb. 21 affirmed that Michael's 1989 marriage to a woman was legal and then took the extraordinary step of granting Michael primary custody of the couple's two children.

"The case took nearly five years, but I am happy and eternally relieved for the children," says Michael, a meat department manager. "Everybody has made this such a big case. But from my perspective, we are a normal family. And now we can get on with our lives."

The breakup battle between Michael and his now ex-wife, Linda, was vicious even by the notoriously cruel standards set by so many of the estranged couples who end up in American courtrooms.

And Judge Gerard J. O'Brien deserves a hearty round of applause -- not because he happened to end up siding with the wishes of a transgendered parent but because of how sensibly he dealt both with the reality that Michael has changed his gender and that it's in the two children's best interests to have strong relationships with their father, as well as their mother.

Read more story below....

In deciding that the children should live with Michael, the judge stressed that Michael, unlike his ex-wife, wants the children to be close to both parents. The judge pointed to a mountain of evidence indicating that Linda tried to destroy Michael's connection to their children by, for example, starting to refer to him as "he/she/it."

Linda knew Michael was transgendered when she married him, according to court documents. Nevertheless, she tried to have their marriage declared invalid after he filed for divorce. She also sought custody of both of their children -- a son, whom Michael adopted after the boy's biological father abandoned Linda during pregnancy, and a daughter, born through artificial insemination with sperm donated by Michael's brother.

Linda apparently developed an uncontrollable hatred for Michael after he told her that he'd developed "feelings" for her best friend. And Linda proceeded to tell the unsuspecting children that their father had been born biologically female.

After a televised three-week trial, the first to include extensive expert testimony about the medical and psychological aspects of being transgendered, O'Brien handed down a staggering 809-page opinion. (See: www.nclrights.org )

"When judges have the chance to understand what it is like for someone to be born in the wrong body, to understand how much people suffer and how the treatment turns them around, they will do the right thing," said co-counsel Shannon Minter of the National Center for Lesbian Rights.

Before Michael's victory, marriages involving transgendered people had been upheld in California and New Jersey. But in Texas and Kansas, they were declared invalid: A transgendered widow had unsuccessfully tried to sue a doctor for medical malpractice over her husband's death; a son inherited his father's estate by having the man's marriage to a transgendered woman nullified.

"(Michael's) case will have an extraordinary impact," Minter predicts. "In addition to all the medical testimony, there was testimony about transgendered people's ability to be good parents."

Fortunately, as society's understanding grows, we can expect to see many more rulings that respect the legal rights of transgendered men and women.

Deb Price of The Detroit News writes the first nationally syndicated column on gay issues and is the co-author of "Courting Justice: Gay Men and Lesbians v. the Supreme Court." To find out more about Deb Price and read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate web page at www.creators.com .

COPYRIGHT 2003 CREATORS SYNDICATE, INC.

Share this article:                         del.icio.us digg facebook Email
Sex reassignment now tax deductible 2010-02-03
Trans artist Flo McGarrell killed in Haiti quake 2010-01-27
Obama has first trans appointees 2010-01-06
Administration Adds Gender Identity To Equal Employment Opportunity Policies 2010-01-06
The Kling's the thing: Trans performer talks 2009-12-09
LOCAL NEWS Forum held on Hunters' ID policy 2009-12-02
Transgender Day of Remembrance 2009-11-25
Discussion tonight on Hunters door policy 2009-11-23
State Changes Trans-ID Policy 2009-11-18
Trans officer talks about library case 2009-11-18
IL Issues Accurate Birth Certificates to Three Transgender Persons 2009-11-11
Trans health pros address needs, risks 2009-11-04
Center welcomes trans liaison 2009-10-28
Letter: Transition in Idaho? 2009-10-28
Stop Trans Pathologization Action Day, Oct. 17 2009-10-15
Letters: Trans collection; letter from Kennedy 2009-09-23
Think Tank on Transgender Student-Athletes Equal Opportunity to convene in Indianapolis 2009-09-23
TransEpiscopal: Making the church more inclusive 2009-09-09
LOCAL NEWS Hunters' trans-ID controversy 2009-09-09
Local library boasts trans collection 2009-09-09
Transfusions and gay men: One case 2009-08-19
Frank introduces trans-inclusive ENDA bill 2009-07-01
Frank introduces trans-inclusive ENDA 2009-06-24
Cher's kid to change gender 2009-06-17
Cher's kid to change gender 2009-06-17
HRC and GLAAD Statements Regarding Chaz Bono's Announcement of Transitioning Genders 2009-06-10
Video for International Day Against Homophobia & Transphobia hits Internet 2009-05-13
Schroer prevails vs. library 2009-05-06
Transgender Veteran Gets Maximum Compensation in case Against Library of Congress 2009-04-29
Forum centers on older trans persons 2009-04-22
Reps hosting transportation forum 2009-04-15
Trans aging intensive at Center April 17 2009-04-08
The Baton: 40 and fabulous 2009-03-18
UIC's center hosts town hall 2009-03-18
Transition matters 2009-02-04
Transnation: Bush is out, RuPaul is in 2009-02-01
TRANSNATION 2009: A preview of the trans year to come 2009-01-21
Transition matters: LGBT news and Obama 2009-01-07
Morten, Madigan make transitions 2008-12-31
TRANSNATION 2008 trans year in review 2008-12-31
Paging Dr. Bowers: Talking about Sex Change Hospital 2008-12-17
Trans aging program set for Dec. 5 2008-12-03
A night of transgender remembrance 2008-11-19
Youth group plans trans community celebration 2008-11-12
Web site finds jobs for trans individuals 2008-11-05
Court: Library can't discriminate against transgender 2008-09-24
Top Model' announces trans finalist 2008-09-01
'Top Model' announces trans finalist 2008-08-20
Transitions Bookplace closes 2008-08-20
Athlete says steroids changed his gender 2008-08-20
Forum focuses on trans people and religion 2008-08-13
Celebrities get things cooking at The Chopping Block 2008-07-30
Positively Aware looks at trans community 2008-07-09
Pregnant transman gives birth 2008-07-09
Pregnant transman gives birth 2008-07-02
Historic trans hearing takes place in Congress 2008-07-02
TRANSNATION Baby Dee: Cleveland's harp-playing, tricycle-riding transgender legend 2008-06-25
Top trans events this Pride season 2008-06-25
Forum focuses on trans community and sexism 2008-05-21
Out at CHM looks at trans history 2008-05-14
Feminist icon Helen Reddy at Transitions 2008-04-30
Law firm involved in trans case opens 2008-04-16
Pop Culture, Queer Culture: An Interview with Roz Kaveney 2008-04-16
Pregnant transman on Oprah 2008-04-09
Views: Thomas Beatie's pregnancy: What does it change? 2008-04-09
Pregnant Transman to Appear on Oprah 2008-04-02
Kimberly Peirce: 'Loss' in Translation 2008-03-26
Helping Trans Kids Out of the Shadows 2008-03-19
Pro-Trans Ruling in Name Case 2008-02-20
Reality Dating, TransAmerican Style 2008-02-20
Island Girls transgender group anniversary 2008-02-13
Keisling Visits Center on Halsted 2008-02-13
Burr on board of directors 2008-02-06
TransNation: The Trans Year to Come 2008-01-09
TransNation: 2007 Trans Year In Review 2008-01-02
TransNation Portland's Not-So-Good Queer 2007-12-26
Year in Review: Transitions 2007-12-26
Trans Veteran Can Sue Library of Congress 2007-12-05
Trans community holds vigil 2007-11-21
WEEK OF 'T' RIGHTS: Trans protest, confront HRC in Chicago 2007-11-21
ABA creates commission on gay, gender ID bias 2007-11-21
No-Trans ENDA Passes 2007-11-14
Trans-Less ENDA Passes House 2007-11-07
Theater: Translations 2007-11-07
The Struggles of Homeless Trans Youth 2007-10-31
Trans-Rights Activists Picket Pelosi Appearance 2007-10-24
Trans-Less ENDA Passes House Committee 2007-10-17
L Word Stars at GenderPAC Cook-Off 2007-10-10
Transgender Activists Protest HRC Dinner 2007-10-10
Groups Back Trans-Inclusion 2007-10-03
Not Without Our 'T' 2007-10-03
The OutField: Transformation, A Sportswriter's Journey to Fulfillment 2007-09-12
Trans Health Conference Sept. 5-8 2007-08-29
Knight at the Movies:Transformers 2007-07-04
AMA Adopts Trans-Inclusive Nondiscrimination Policy 2007-07-04
AMA Adopts Trans-Inclusive Nondiscrimination Policy 2007-07-01
Trans Rocker's A Little Bit Country 2007-06-27
Transgression: Windy City Times Fourth Annual Literary Supplement 2007-06-20
Intersex Activist Discusses Recent Controversy 2007-06-01
Intersex Activist Discusses Recent Controversy 2007-05-16
State Reps Mock Trans Bill 2007-04-25
TransNation 2007-04-25
SRLP Founder Fights For Trans Survival 2007-04-11
Local Gay Club Allegedly Turns Away Trans Individuals 2007-04-04
FLORIDA HEAT: CITY FIGHTS TRANS POL 2007-03-14
TransNation: Kindred Spirits 2007-01-10
TransNation: 2006 in Review 2007-01-10
Rage Against the Machine 2007-01-03
Milwaukee LGBT Center Starts Trans Project 2006-12-27
Washington Transition Turmoil 2006-12-20
Trans Vigil Calls for End to Violence 2006-12-08
Transference 2006-12-06
All My Children Introduces Trans Character 2006-12-06
Trans Vigil Calls for End to Violence 2006-11-29
Vigil for Trans Hate-Crime Victims Nov. 20 2006-11-15
Man Killed Had Been Charged with Transmitting HIV 2006-08-23
BOOK REVIEW: Just Add Hormones: An Insider's Guide to the Transsexual Experience, by Matt Kailey 2006-08-02
Police: No 'War' Between Trans and Gays That Led to July Murder 2006-08-02
Gloria Allred: Talking About a Girl Like Gwen 2006-06-21
Gallery Brings 'Vision' to Transgendered Artists 2006-06-21
$2.5M Bond Set in Transgender Murder 2006-04-26
Study on Minority Trans Youth and HIV 2006-03-15
Trans-formational 2006-03-01
GENDER RIGHTS FIGHT 2006-02-22
Trans Challenge Wisconsin Law 2006-02-01
Doctor for Trans Dies 2006-02-01
Gay Films Win Globes Brokeback, Transamerica and Capote Take Awards 2006-01-18
U of C Trans Forum 2006-01-11
Transition: Duncan Tucker 2005-12-21
Knight at the Movies: Transamerica and Breakfast on Pluto 2005-12-21
Trans Vigil Marked with 14 Candles 2005-11-23
Trans Day of Remembrance Nov. 20 2005-11-16
Group Praises Indy Mayor for Trans Law 2005-11-16
Trans-Inclusive Hate-Crime Bill Makes Way thru Congress 2005-11-01
Trans-Inclusive Hate Crimes Bill Passes House 2005-09-28
Dahir Views: Cold water poured on transgender refugee 2005-09-21
Trans Documentary Screens in Chicago 2005-09-14
Trans Film Screening 2005-09-01
Muslims disrupt transvestite pageant 2005-07-06
Transgender Applicant Sues Congress for Job Discrimination 2005-06-22
Transgender Pharmacist Prevails in Colorado 2005-06-01
Trans-Inclusive Hate-Crimes Bill Introduced in House 2005-06-01
Nepal: Police Attack Transgender 2005-05-01
Trans Custody Loss 2005-02-23
Parents, Trans Clash 2004-12-22
Trans Murder Vigil 2004-11-24
Trans Day of Remembrance 2004-11-17
HRC Moves to Add Trans to ENDA 2004-08-11
Living Inside Myself 2004-07-28
Transgender Youth Kit 2004-07-01
Transgenders Winning Over the Arts and Minds 2004-07-01
Mistrial in Murder of Trans Teen 2004-06-30
Youth: TYRA (Trans Youth Resource and Advocacy) 2004-04-28
GENDER: LCCP's Grimes 'Comes Out' as Trans 2004-04-01
Lambda Settles UPS Transfer Case 2004-03-17
Health/Fitness: Battle of the Trans 2004-01-21
Year in Review:Transitions 2003-12-24
17 Trans Deaths Remembered 2003-11-26
Trans Vigil Nov. 19 2003-11-19
Trannies Denied Registration 2003-11-01
TYRA Starts 2003-10-01
Trans Murders Rock Community 2003-10-01
Another Trans Murder 2003-09-17
Trans Murders Rock D.C. Community 2003-08-27
Trans Group Attacks New Book on 'Queens' 2003-06-25
VIEWS: THE TRANSGENDER COMMUNITY & ENDA 2003-06-18
Trans Killed 2003-06-01
VIEWS In the Child's Best Interests, by Miranda Stevens-Miller 2003-05-07
Transgender Father Loses Custody 2003-04-16
Leno Accused of Trans Hate 2003-04-09
The Price of Invisibility 2003-04-09
Who Cares About Trans Youth? 2003-03-19
TRANSSEXUAL MARRIAGE UPHELD 2003-03-05
NY Trans Rights Fight and Judge's Rulings Favor Latino AIDS Agency in Transgender Discrimination Suit 2003-01-22
BRITAIN PLANS TRANSSEXUAL RIGHTS 2003-01-08
Chilean Trans Protest Killings 2003-01-01
Singer Allowed To Switch Gender 2003-01-01
Boston Trans rights 2002-10-30
Death of a Unicorn 2002-10-30
Trans Murder in California 2002-10-23
Candlelight Vigil Set for Trans Day 2002-10-23
U of C Center opens 2002-10-16
Anti-Hate March for Shepard, Trans 2002-10-09
Candlelight Vigil Set for Trans Day 2002-10-01
Shepard March to Focus on Rights for Trans 2002-10-01
Norton Gets Assurances of Hate Crime Treatment of Murdered Teens 2002-10-01
Crossdressers need not apply 2002-09-25
Candlelight Vigil Set for Transgender Day 2002-09-18
Shepard March to Focus on Rights for Trans 2002-09-18
THE EDUCATION OF HELEN SHAVER: From playing a lesbian to trans 2001-10-03
TRANS ACTIVIST SETTLES WITH DUSABLE 2001-06-06
STUDY: TRANSGENDERED AT HIGH RISK FOR HIV, VIOLENCE, STRESS 2001-05-23
STUDY: TRANSGENDERED AT HIGH RISK FOR HIV, VIOLENCE, STRESS 2001-05-23
Club 86 "And The Wiener Is … " 2001-05-16
TRANSGENESIS GETS ROOM OF ITS OWN 2001-04-25
Families Like Mine: Happy Anniversary, Mom and Parent! 2001-03-28
CHICAGO IS HOME TO FIRST INSTITUTE FOR TRANS RESEARCH AND EDUCATION 2001-03-21
Miranda writes ... That lingering trans bias 2001-02-21
Miranda Writes… About da Bathroom Issue 2001-02-14
ACTIVIST ACCUSES MUSEUM OF BIAS: TRANS BIAS ALLEGED AGAINST DUSABLE 2001-01-17
Trans Forum Covers Many Issues 2000-10-10
HRC: Birch on Trans Issues 1999-09-01






 
 
 
 
 
 

 
 

Copyright © 2010 Windy City Media Group. All rights reserved.
Reprint by permission only. Back issues available for $3 per issue (postage included). Return postage must accompany all manuscripts,
drawings, and photographs submitted if they are to be returned, and no responsibility may be assumed for unsolicited materials.
All rights to letters, art and photos sent to Nightspots (Chicago GLBT Nightlife News) and
Windy City Times (a Chicago Gay and Lesbian News and Feature Publication) will be treated as unconditionally assigned for publication
purposes and as such, subject to editing and comment. The opinions expressed by the columnists, cartoonists, letter writers, and commentators
are their own and do not necessarily reflect the position of Nightspots (Chicago GLBT Nightlife News) and
Windy City Times (a Chicago Gay and Lesbian News and Feature Publication).

The appearance of a name, image or photo of a person or group in
Nightspots (Chicago GLBT Nightlife News) and Windy City Times (a Chicago Gay and Lesbian News and Feature Publication)
does not indicate the sexual orientation of such individuals or groups.
While we encourage readers to support the advertisers who make this newspaper possible,
Nightspots (Chicago GLBT Nightlife News) and
Windy City Times (a Chicago Gay and Lesbian News and Feature Publication) cannot accept responsibility for advertising claims.

Windy City Media Group produces Windy City Queercast, and publishes Windy City Times,
The Weekly Voice of the Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual and Trans Community,
Nightspots, Out! Resource Guide, and Identity.
5315 N. Clark St. #192, Chicago, IL 60640-2113 • PH (773) 871-7610 • FAX (773) 871-7609.
www.windycitymediagroup.com
contact editor  •  contact advertising  •  contact webmaster

Website Powered by Materville Studios / LoveYourWebsite.com

 



cheerful-nonunion