Windy City Media Group Frontpage News Home
CELEBRATING 28+ YEARS OF Lesbian Gay Bisexual and Transgender NEWS

Search Gay News Articles
Advanced Search
Gay News Sponsor Windy City Times 2014-07-30
Download Issue
  News Index       Archives   About WCMG    Publications    Bars & Clubs     Calendar   Videos   Advertisers    OUT! Guide    Classifieds   AIDS @ 32
 Local | National | World | Politics | Obits | Profiles | Views | Entertainment | Theater | Dance | Music | Film | Art | Books | TV/Gossip
 Travel | History | Marriage | Youth | Trans | Lesbian | Celebrations | Food | Nightlife | Sports | Health | Real Estate | Autos | Pets | Crime

Knight at the Movies: Marvel's Guardians...; Lucy; film notes Knight at the Movies: Marvel's 
Guardians...;
Lucy; film notes
Even the most casual follower of current events must be aware of ...

Browse Gay News Index   Browse Gay News Archives
  Identity

Yasmin Nair The Gay Movement Is Over
by Yasmin Nair
2006-10-01

facebook twitter del.icio.us stumble upon digg google +1 reddit email


PART I: THE TROUBLE WITH OPPRESSION

In 2005, the gay press reported that two men were hanged for consensual sexual relations on July 19 in the town of Mashad, Iran. The story that they had been punished for being lovers was especially propagated by writer Doug Ireland on his blog. But such notions were quickly debunked by activists like Scott Long of Human Rights Watch ( HRW ) and critically analyzed by writers and journalists like Bill Andriette ( www.guidemag.com/content/index.cfm ) and Richard Kim ( www.thenation.com/doc/20050815/kim ) . This year, an assortment of groups backed by leaders of the 'global gay community' like Peter Tatchell declared that July 19 would be 'The International Day of Action against Homophobic Persecution in Iran.' Commemorations were to include worldwide protests, and the International Gay and Lesbian Human Rights Commission ( IGLHRC ) was among the sponsors. Significantly, Al Fateha, the biggest queer Muslim organization in the U.S., did not endorse the protest. But there was widespread dissent among queers about the politics of the event, and IGLHRC eventually withdrew its support. Instead, with HRW, it organized a community forum that conflicted with the protest outside the Iranian embassy in New York.

The flurry of acronyms hides the fact that the criticism came from individuals like me as well as organizations. What follows is an account of how radical and progressive queers expressed and mobilized dissent against this event. It details the extent to which so-called Leftist gay leaders are willing to use the strategies of the Right. The story reveals that the trouble with the putative fight against homophobic oppression is that it draws upon conflicting impulses of solidarity and imperialism. In the rush towards establishing a transcendent global gay identity, there may not be much difference between the two.

Despite the claims of organizers that they wanted to work in solidarity with Iranian and other oppressed gays everywhere, I initiated a critique of the protest on the queerfist listserv ( www.queerfist.org ) that was taken up by others, and eventually suggested that dissenters contact sponsoring organizations to withdraw their support. We were wary of perpetuating a U.S.-led hostility towards a country that Bush once declared part of an 'axis of evil.' The idea that the two men were gay lovers, not rapists or murderers, seemed the only basis of mobilizing the gay community's outrage against the hangings.

But, I asked, why base a critique of the wanton use of the death penalty solely on the notion of innocence and the claim that the two were in lovers? If they had been rapists and murderers, would that make the punishment more acceptable? In that case, this Day of Action was extremely limited in its understanding of social justice.

Critics also took issue with Doug Ireland's claim that gay Muslims seek a 'self-affirming gay identity.' They countered that not all gays subscribed to mainstream American notions of an exact match between sexual identity and practice. From Beirut, Daniel Drennan wrote a nuanced and incisive critique of Ireland's positions. He was especially critical of the posture of rescue that the 'West' tends to adopt in relation to the 'East' and wrote, 'Please give it a rest. We are very tired of the ongoing 'interventions' on our behalf.'

PART 2: SHE'S NO HOMO!

Ireland's responses to criticism became increasingly more febrile, and he suggested that I was among the 'sectarian apologists for the Islamic Republic of Iran.' I am not, and was shocked that someone who claimed leftist politics would use McCarthyesque tactics to smear his opponents. Finally, Ireland lost journalistic credibility with a single e-mail. He forwarded, without comment, a message from someone who had been involved in activist groups in Chicago. The message was a series of ad hominems and included a claim about my sex life ( I'm happy to forward a copy to anyone ) . But one comment stuck out '…she has never had to face what it means to be a homo.'

Ah, I thought. Yes, perhaps. After all, this whole out-queer-woman-of-color-with-a-noticeably-Muslim-name-in-a-post-9/11-world thing will only take a lifetime to negotiate. The next time I'm pulled aside for a 'random search,' I'll remember my relatively privileged position vis-à-vis white gay men like Ireland, click my heels Dorothy-style and chant 'I'm no homo' three times in the hopes of being whisked away to Kansas. Where I will be stared at and denied service because of the color of my skin. Which will never compare to being a homo.

I don't, of course, believe in a hierarchy of oppressions. My point from the start had been that we could not argue against a horrible action against gay men without and outside of relevant contexts—such as global politics and gender oppression—in Iran and the U.S. Yet, here was Ireland attempting to silence me on the grounds that my supposed non-homo-ness and my gender made my critique irrelevant. Posting an e-mail about my sex life was a weak attempt to discredit and, presumably, shame me. It made him no different from right-wing ideologues who ferret out salacious details about opponents in order to shut them up. Ann Coulter, meet Doug Ireland.

Unable to counter my political critique, he proved that there were no sustainable politics of social justice behind the protest. The event's success depended on manipulating the emotions of people who will only support a 'gay' action if the principals involved led unimpeachable and beautiful gay lives of love and romance. As Long pointed out, organizers of the protest never offered a plan for action that could utilize the energy of the event. Ireland revealed himself as a megalomaniac whose feverish blogging indicates a talent gone awry in the pursuit of narratives of persecution, real or imagined. His constant proximity to the computer screen bears an inverse relationship to his distance from reality.

PART 3: IT'S OVER

What does this tell us about queer politics and the contemporary gay movement? We're so used to thinking that anything LGBTQ is automatically a progressive cause that we have yet to develop a language of dissent among ourselves. A truly progressive movement could absorb and integrate points of critique without deflating into meaningless ad hominems. There can be no doubt that people are repressed, brutalized and killed in many parts of the world, including the U.S., on account of their gender and/or sexuality. But rushing blindly into projects of rescue benefits no one and, as Long and others indicate, the Iran fracas may eventually do more harm than good to the situation of Iranian queers whose accounts are clouded by suspicions of their authenticity.

We are bound to hear more stories like the one in Mashad. It's difficult for individuals not to sympathize, but it's worth asking hard questions about not just the stories but our motivations for rescue. Who tells the story? Who else can corroborate it? What do we really want to gain from endorsing actions on behalf of those oppressed? Is it likely that our need to save others might be motivated by a hope of being glorified by them as their saviours?

Yet, it's difficult for most of us as individuals to stand by and watch atrocities and not respond in some way. I don't endorse the idea that only organizations should do the work of research and negotiation on our behalf, given their uneven politics on most issues. IGLHRC's flip-flopping on the Iran protest is hardly commendable. And most gay organizations endorse gay marriage and hate crimes legislation; neither cause is part of progressive politics. In a perfect world, the work of individual activists and thinkers and rational and even-handed journalists could serve as a counterbalance to the work of organizations. The problem is not that we lack the resources but that radical queer organizing tends to become invisible and unintelligible amidst the cacophony raised by the Gay Right and by organizations that have too much clout and dictate what the 'community' should stand for. An even bigger problem is that we haven't yet come to grips with what we define as a radical or progressive vision in relation to the 'gay/homo' agenda.

Queers stood by uneasily as the Gay Movement moved rightwards in its quest for the status quo, most notably around the issue of gay marriage. Proponents of Gay Marriage ( PGMs ) and most gay organizations can not move beyond asking for acceptance into the mainstream. They are too wedded to the principle of asking for equality. Such rhetoric should not blind us to the fact that the claim for equality rests on the idea that all queers equally want the same thing. As the gay marriage movement demonstrates, the principle of equality is only another way of asking for the status quo. So, for instance, PGMs argue that gays should be able to marry in order to gain health care benefits. Their insistence that this is somehow part of a liberal/progressive gay agenda has taken real health care reform off the radar of progressive organizing. PGMs have yet to articulate a larger vision for social justice that includes health care and benefits for all, not just couples.

It's time to be blunt about the pitfalls of gay marriage. The fight for gay marriage directly contributes to inequality in America. It takes away resources from pressing social concerns and it assumes that only people in coupled relationships are of any consequence. PGMs have even hijacked the immigration rights movement by arguing that the queer partners of citizens should gain a quicker path to citizenship on the grounds of 'life-long commitment' and 'financial interdependence.' [ For more, see www.identitychicago.com/gay/lesbian/news/ARTICLE.php. ] This is unfair to single immigrants; considers them unworthy of any recognition; and reinforces antiquated and heteronormative patterns of relationships.

All of these struggles over the status quo reinforce simplistic ideas about who gets to be 'gay' or 'homo' enough to warrant attention. A gay movement without an expansive notion of queer social justice is doomed to failure. The Iran fracas demonstrates that conservatives among us will always attempt to define our politics by a singular notion of gay and that only gay lives defined by sexual practice and identity are worth noting. If a tree falls in the forest, does it make a sound? If a lesbian goes through life without a partner, is she never a lesbian?

The dissent over the Iran protests signals the end of the Gay Movement as we know it. In its place lies the potential for a more critically self-aware and nuanced queer movement that goes beyond affirming the status quo. It's time for us to end our specious call for equality and seek an end to inequality.

Yasmin Nair is completing her manuscript, Deviancy's Other: Queer Theory, Neo-liberalism, and the Rise of Inequality in America. She is also working on a collection of her essays titled No Homo: How the Left Became Queer and Queers Became the Right. Nair can be reached at welshzen@yahoo.com .

Most of the e-mail exchanges referred to here can be accessed at leftbehinds.blogspot.com/2006/07/doug-ireland-vs-iran-and-yasmin-nair.html ] , at leftbehinds.blogspot.com/2006/07/iran-vs-doug-ireland-pt-iii.html and leftbehinds.blogspot.com/2006/07/more-about-gay-ol-iran.html.


facebook twitter del.icio.us stumble upon digg google +1 reddit email




Windy City Media Group does not approve or necessarily agree with the views posted below.
Please do not post letters to the editor here. Please also be civil in your dialogue.
If you need to be mean, just know that the longer you stay on this page, the more you help us.

World news: Conchita Wurst models; Ian Thorpe comes out 2014-07-16
Gay team makes history; Laverne Cox tops world list 2014-07-08
World news: Developments in Uganda; Luxembourg passes marriage 2014-06-24
Immigrant rights group to FIFA: Use World Cup to speak up 2014-06-24
Internat'l defense act; Canada's gay premier; Mr. World 2014-06-18
World news: Russia HIV law; Brunei delays stoning law 2014-04-23
THEATER REVIEW Depraved New World 2014-04-02
Getting on bi? World premieres touch upon sexual fluidity 2014-04-01
World Vision reverses course on employment policies 2014-03-27
Astraea starts $20 million world push for LGBTQI equality 2014-03-26
World news: Etheridge at WorldPride 2014; raid in China 2014-03-19
SPRING DANCE SPECIAL What's coming in the world of dance 2014-03-18
World news: Uganda fallout; IGLTA scholarships offered 2014-03-05
The Playboy of the Western World 2014-02-19
Vin Diesel dances; 'Sean Saves the World' shuts down 2014-01-28
What's coming in the world of dance 2014-01-22
Putin pours fuel on the controversy 2014-01-20
World news of the year 2013-12-31
Sweet Charity: AIDS Foundation of Chicago's World of Chocolate 2013-12-11
World of Chocolate commemorates World AIDS Day 2013-12-11
LGBT delegation to Honduras reports human-rights abuses 2013-12-10
Uprising of Love: Celebrities support Russian Freedom Fund 2013-12-09
'World of Chocolate' on new day, at new venue 2013-12-04
Vida/SIDA celebrates 25 years with gala on World AIDS Day 2013-12-03
Fashion event marks World AIDS Day 2013-12-03
Vida/SIDA observes World AIDS Day 2013-12-02
World AIDS Day: Presidential proclamation 2013-11-28
DANCING ABOUTARCHITECTURE: LOST TALENT, A WORLD AIDS DAY REMEMBRANCE IN MUSIC 2013-11-27
The little red ribbon that changed the world 2013-11-27
'AIDS diva' Lewis-Thornton on her life and activismWORLD AIDS DAY 2013 2013-11-26
World AIDS Day events 2013-11-24
World AIDS Day at Center on Halsted 2013-11-21
World news: Luxembourg has gay leader; South Korean movie's rating 2013-11-20
Christina Kahrl reflects on World Series, joins GLAAD Board 2013-11-19
World news-FCKH8.com sending shirts to Russia; Barilla makes promise 2013-11-06
World news 2013-11-06
Sec. of State Kerry speaks at UN LGBT event 2013-09-27
UN LGBT group issues statement on ending anti-gay violence 2013-09-27
'Sean Saves the World' reunites 'Smash' co-stars 2013-09-18
A Queer Agenda: A Fierce World Is Possible 2013-09-18





Copyright © 2014 Windy City Media Group. All rights reserved.
Reprint by permission only. PDFs for back issues are downloadable from
the online archives. Single copies of back issues in print form are
available for $4 per issue, older than one month for $6 if available,
by check to the mailing address listed below.

Return postage must accompany all manuscripts, drawings, and
photographs submitted if they are to be returned, and no
responsibility may be assumed for unsolicited materials.
All rights to letters, art and photos sent to Nightspots
(Chicago GLBT Nightlife News) and Windy City Times (a Chicago
Gay and Lesbian News and Feature Publication) will be treated
as unconditionally assigned for publication purposes and as such,
subject to editing and comment. The opinions expressed by the
columnists, cartoonists, letter writers, and commentators are
their own and do not necessarily reflect the position of Nightspots
(Chicago GLBT Nightlife News) and Windy City Times (a Chicago Gay,
Lesbian, Bisexual and Transegender News and Feature Publication).

The appearance of a name, image or photo of a person or group in
Nightspots (Chicago GLBT Nightlife News) and Windy City Times
(a Chicago Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual and Transgender News and Feature
Publication) does not indicate the sexual orientation of such
individuals or groups. While we encourage readers to support the
advertisers who make this newspaper possible, Nightspots (Chicago
GLBT Nightlife News) and Windy City Times (a Chicago Gay, Lesbian
News and Feature Publication) cannot accept responsibility for
any advertising claims or promotions.

 

 

 



 

First couple to adopt looks back
 
Illinois takes step to end trans insurance bias
 
MUSIC Lakeside Pride Freedom Band director Zurcher resigns on a high note
 
A Gay in the Life: Rick Aguilar
 
SCOTTISH PLAY SCOTT Grand-scale Greek drama
 
Windy City Times Current DownloadNightspots Current DownloadQueercast Current Download
Windy City Media Group BlogsJoin Our Email List!Donate Now








  News Index       Archives   About WCMG    Publications    Bars & Clubs     Calendar   Videos   Advertisers    OUT! Guide    Classifieds   AIDS @ 32
 Local | National | World | Politics | Obits | Profiles | Views | Entertainment | Theater | Dance | Music | Film | Art | Books | TV/Gossip
 Travel | History | Marriage | Youth | Trans | Lesbian | Celebrations | Food | Nightlife | Sports | Health | Real Estate | Autos | Pets | Crime



About WCMG      Contact Us      Online Front  Page      Windy City  Times      Nightspots      OUT! Guide     
Identity      BLACKlines      En La Vida      Archives      Subscriptions      Distribution      Windy City Queercast     
Queercast Archives      Advertising  Rates      Deadlines      Advanced Search     
Press  Releases      Event Photos      Join WCMG  Email List      Email Blast     
Upcoming Events      Todays Events      Ongoing Events      Post an Event      Bar Guide      Community Groups      In Memoriam      Outguide Categories      Outguide Advertisers      Search Outguide      Travel      Dining Out      Blogs      Spotlight  Video      News Videos      Nightspots Videos      Entertainment Videos      Queercast Videos      Comedy Videos     
Classifieds      Real Estate      Place a  Classified     

Windy City Media Group produces Windy City Queercast, & publishes Windy City Times,
The Weekly Voice of the Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual and Trans Community,
Nightspots, Out! Resource Guide, and Identity.
5315 N. Clark St. #192, Chicago, IL 60640-2113 • PH (773) 871-7610 • FAX (773) 871-7609.